
Burlington police got calls about a gunshot near City Market at 2:14 a.m. Sunday. Two earlier gunfire calls on nearby blocks came at 2:18 a.m.: one in the parking lot at Main Street and South Winooski Avenue in September 2025, and one on Main Street between Church Street and South Winooski in March 2024.
Those calls land in the middle of a fight over downtown safety. Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak says “overall violent crime continues to trend downward.” City Council President Ben Traverse, a Democrat who is running for mayor, says the city’s public safety problems haven’t been met “with enough urgency.”
Both can be true. Violent crime can fall across the city while the same late-night hour keeps producing gunfire calls. Of 64 gunfire incidents Burlington police recorded citywide from 2012 through early September 2022, 10 occurred between 2:01 and 3 a.m., more than in any other hour. Under state law, bars can sell alcohol until 2 a.m.
What Happened Sunday
Police said a verbal argument came before the shot. The man pointed a handgun and fired one round into the ground toward the other person. Officers arrived about a minute after the calls, but he was gone. No one was hurt. Police are looking for a man about 5 feet 10 inches tall, wearing a black zip-up hooded jacket over a white shirt and dark pants.
Police have classified the case as reckless endangerment, which under Vermont law means putting someone in danger of death or serious injury. It carries up to a year in jail, and the law presumes that pointing a gun at or toward someone is reckless.
City Market closes at 9 p.m., more than five hours before the call. The store stands on the city-owned site of Burlington’s old police station.
The case comes in Chief Anthony Geraci’s first week. The City Council confirmed him 10-2 on Nov. 9, and he took over Tuesday. In October the department reported 54 sworn officers out of roughly 73 positions.
The Same Few Blocks
In the September 2025 case, a fight broke out among several people and a man fired a handgun into the air, scattering the crowd. In the March 2024 case, a man was shot during an altercation. Police charged a 19-year-old with attempted murder, and he later pleaded guilty to aggravated assault with a weapon and simple assault.
Sunday’s shot was at least the fourth after-midnight gunfire incident downtown this year:
July 5, about 12:19 a.m.: Police say a man fired one shot at a group near Church and Main streets when there was a large crowd downtown.
Aug. 15: Shots on Church Street near King Street after two men argued.
Aug. 16, about 1:44 a.m.: Officers on Church Street foot patrol heard a single shot from Center Street. A woman was charged after her pistol went off while she checked whether it was loaded.
After the July shooting, then-Interim Chief Shawn Burke said that what used to become “potentially a fist fight in front of one of the clubs downtown” now often becomes a case where someone “brandishes or brandishes and fires a firearm.”
The Mayor’s Case
Mulvaney-Stanak’s case rests on the overall numbers. After a violent weekend in August, she said police were expanding foot patrols and proactive enforcement while rebuilding staffing. She said they were also using a “hot spots” strategy, which concentrates officers where problems cluster, and that officers were assigned downtown when each of that weekend’s incidents happened.
Gunfire is down from its peak. Burlington averaged about two gunfire incidents a year before 2020, then hit 26 in 2022 and 16 in 2023, and 15 in 2024. At the Oct. 27 Police Commission meeting, Burke reported that violent crime had dropped, “particularly in the downtown district.”
Traverse’s Case
Traverse’s case rests on what people see. “From my perspective Burlington is stuck at the moment,” he said when he announced on Nov. 6. “What have you seen move forward over the last three years?” He said the administration “has failed to deliver” on key promises, including public safety.
The same October report gives him a point too. Burke told the commission that foot patrols and directed patrols, which send officers to specific trouble spots, “have kind of fallen off a little bit” this year for lack of staff and are “just not where we were in 2025.”
The Burlington Forward resolution Traverse co-wrote calls for more police presence downtown and stronger enforcement against illegal drug use. Council Progressives argue it will do more harm than good, and the council has put off a vote until Dec. 7. Mulvaney-Stanak has not said whether she will seek a second term.
The department has not published an hour-by-hour gunfire count since 2022. That leaves no public answer to whether the 2 a.m. hour has followed the broader drop.
Where the Mayor and Traverse Agree
On guns and alcohol, the mayor and her challenger stand together. In January both went to the Statehouse to push a change to Burlington’s charter, the city’s founding rules, which the Legislature must approve. The change would ban guns in bars. Traverse said “mixing guns and alcohol puts lives at risk.” The mayor said 86.6 percent of Burlington voters support it and “it’s our responsibility to honor that democratic decision.”
The Legislature didn’t pass it. A statewide ban, S.329, passed the Senate in May and was sent to the House Judiciary Committee on May 13, where it went no further. Had it reached Gov. Phil Scott’s desk, it was likely to face a veto. Gun-rights groups such as the Vermont Federation of Sportsmen’s Clubs testified against the Burlington ban.
Police have said the shot was fired near City Market. They have not said whether either person had been inside a bar.
The council takes up Burlington Forward again Dec. 7. The Legislature returns in January.
Anyone with information about Sunday’s shooting can call Burlington police at (802) 658-2700.


